poetry critical

online poetry workshop



Just a Shallow Girl
SweetPain

Filling with your vanity
 1
this shallow pool of blood;
 2
no longer floating slow and frothy to the top
 3
but falling to the bottom,
 4
a shallow wingless drone.
 5

11 Mar 05

Rated 8 (7.7) by 2 users.
Active (2): 8, 8
Inactive (13): 1, 6, 6, 6, 7, 7, 7, 7, 8, 10, 10, 10, 10

(define the words in this poem)
(108 more poems by this author)

(1 user considers this poem a favorite)



Add A Comment:
Enter the following text to post as unknown: captcha

Comments:

comments?
 — SweetPain

non, well this is a first.
 — SweetPain

vague but good imagery.
 — unknown

Thank you very much unknown.
 — unknown

Nothing more to say about this poem at all?
 — SweetPain

You seemed so desperate for some input. I can see it as I read it. I'm not sure what you were going for though.
 — Othrwize

its just about a shallow girl i dont particulary agree. -SweetPain-
 — unknown

i sense a bitter but sweet jelousy in this poem...
 — mike

the grammar isn't correct ("bottom" "the lump of crap" in | 3) much less does it have any poetic merit.
 — unknown

well thankyou mike and unknown. i take both of your critiques to heart.
 — SweetPain

i changed around the last line, thank you for all your help.
 — SweetPain

Cool poem, i like it.....has meaning to me!!...
 — crazy

i wouldn't use shallow in l1, because it feels too redundant and loses its punch.  i would take it out completely in the whole poem except for the title.  i think i'd change l3 to: "but fall to the bottom like the rest of them".  i think that way you aren't being too wordy.
 — sassybnyss

FUCKING LOVE THIS POEM!!! IT'S REALLY GREAT!
 — boyboy

thanx to crazy, boy boy and to sassybnyss i dont really agree with you sorry darlin'. but im am totally and completly shocked at these rating. im actually kind of baffled, this poem really isnt that great.
 — SweetPain

I... don't know how i feel about it. At first I really didn't like it, then I was like, well maybe its ok, and now I see some deeper implications in it. I think I would like it a lot if it was longer and well- just more about something.
 — Cloudless

thankyou for being specific Cloudless. *confused look*
 — SweetPain

but thanx anyhow.
 — SweetPain

this rings with truth.  good job.
 — themolly

i'm reading what themollyreads cos it's a sort of releasing of decision that i dig right now.

work with your layout maybe
and swap the first half and last half of the first line around maybe so you have a stronger start
 — kaleidazcope

thankyou Kaleidazcope, and themolly.
 — SweetPain

is this what you ment Kaleidazcope?
 — SweetPain

interesting, very deep, not sure I got all of it. 7
 — sweetascandy

i dont get all of it either. thankyou sweetascandy!
 — SweetPain

I like this one, so I'll hopefully give it a long critique.  Your title could be more simple , like Shallow Girl.
i'm going to take the liberty of helping this one out. You have very good stuff here though, It could just be a bit more, add more adjectives, and work on the layout.

"This shallow pool
Filled with deep crimson red
Swallowed by your vanity

Floating slow and frothy
no  longer.
Falling to the dismay.

Shallow drones
sitting at the bottome
Waiting for my arrival"

Erm... that's kind of a bad example but you get the picture. what you have is good otherwise.
 — Gabriella

thankyou Gabriella!
 — SweetPain

Shallow drones implies bees, not a girl, to my mind.

I think it's the presentation that's not right.  Try shorter lines.  

Filling with your vanity
this shallow pool of blood;
no longer floating slow and frothy to the top
but falling to the bottom,
a shallow wingless drone.

See the difference in intensity?  When a poem is this short, it has to be close and tight to make it powerful.

My humble O only, of course.
 — Isabelle5

made me cry, wow, nice?

-Sam' xx
 — unknown

thanks you very much Isabelle5 and Sam! - SweetPain -
 — unknown

changes made, i like this version better, thankyou very much Isabelle5.
 — SweetPain

SP - ^that comment wasn't from me. I am not critiquing poems 'til this settles. Ignore any of those comments.
 — sam

I love it this way.  
 — Isabelle5

i feel so bad for you sam :(, that asshole should be shot. and thanks isabelle5, of course you love it this way :P
 — SweetPain

ewww, frothy blood!!
 — unknown

yes, frothy blood, lol.
 — SweetPain

  slip, worker bee, depth.

sediment, hmm..
 — Meep

0.364s