poetry critical

online poetry workshop



Returning Ghosts Dance
Isabelle5

The grave looks cold from above
 1
but nestled in smooth satin,
 2
bones are warm enough.
 3
 
 
Spirits flowing through the grass
 4
pause to thank the skin they wore
 5
before they turn their newly opened eyes
 6
to Light and diamond studded space,
 7
 
 
where the voice of their own eternity
 8
meets the voices of the stars,
 9
sending out shock waves of joyous laughter
 10
as souls return from where they first began
 11
and their reunion dance resembles  
 12
Aurora Borealis from below.
 13

24 Aug 05

Rated 7 (7.6) by 3 users.
Active (3): 3, 8, 10
Inactive (4): 3, 8, 9, 10

(define the words in this poem)
(248 more poems by this author)

(2 users consider this poem a favorite)



Add A Comment:
Enter the following text to post as unknown: captcha

Comments:

somewhat obscure
 — unknown

Hmm, in what way?  It's my impression of a happy homecoming and happiness reaching Earth in sweeping gorgeous colors.

Maybe it's a matter of "who cares?"  lol
 — Isabelle5

Oh, that's the thing I mentioned on the thread.  Every single poem I read this morning has it and I watched as poem after poem appeared on the recently commented list and when I checked, there this thing was.  Someone had too much time.

Thanks for calling this pretty.  I'm reading it myself wondering if poetry has to have a point, as this one has it's beauty but not much of a concrete point.

Kind of like I feel sometimes!  lol
 — Isabelle5

'where the voices of their own eternity
meets those of the stars'

or

'where the voice of their own eternity
met those of the stars'

pretty cool otherwise...
 — dedication

this will be my first favourite. it's so BEAUTIFUL! it's like you give the greatest respect for the dead. i love this.
 — Mahagnare

abstract
 — unknown

Good start, liked the first stanza and opening to the second (reminds me of those sequences in 'Gladiator' where he runs his hand across the flowing grass) but I think this could be better - particularly the ending lacked vigor for me, which is a shame as potentially its a very stirring image. Could it be reworded?
 — b00

Where the forgotten meet,
spinning wildly, we see
The Northern Lights –
the trite spectacle of
our ultimate union.

(just thought of this - it's how I'd do it; though our styles differ of course, its an example)
 — b00

Where the newly passed
are joined by ancient stars,
spinning wildly, we see
The Northern Lights –
sheets of sparks cast off
from an awesome union.  

(sorry the juices are flowing now lol)
 — b00

I am still not happy with the ending myself.  I've changed it several times, think I have it and then it complains that I'm not listening to the Muse too well.  Thanks for the comments.

ps - I do respect the dead!  They did their race already and get to know everything.  I can't wait for my chance to dance among the stars!
 — Isabelle5

How about the living dead ; )
 — unknown

I hear ya Isabelle5 :-)

can I recommend you read my poem 'such steady sleep' for my thoughts on life/death; for many years I've courted death as a release from the trauma of living, but now I finally enjoy living, I fear the trauma of dying! hehe  
 — b00

Read it, liked it a lot.  I don't plan to sleep when I die, I plan to have energy and do everything, read everything, visit everywhere and know every single fact about every single thing!  No rest for the mentally hungry!
 — Isabelle5

this poem is beautiful. I especially like: pause to thank the skin they wore
 — misswyoming

well I hope we're both right and you get to read everything and I get some serious shut-eye  :-)
 — b00

actually I'm reading 'the five people you meet when you die'

highly recommend it - some beautiful images of the afterlife, which, apparently, is designed to help us understand our lives on earth; maybe you will get to know everything...
 — b00

silly
 — unknown

Yes, isn't it fun?
 — unknown

beautiful and quite unique. poems of death there are aplenty, but this puts a happy, homecoming-ish spin on what comes after time on earth is done. isabelle, you've done it again! i would leave this as is, none of the changes suggested in the comments touch the original.
-Catbox, too lazy to sign in
 — unknown

I read the last comment after returning from a 2 hour lunch that was supposed to be only 45 minutes.  Got lost on two different freeways and those of you in So Ca will get this - I'm trying to get back to Long Beach and find myself at Alton Parkway, shouting, "Where the fuck is the 405 North?!?!"  I got back hungry, my clothes were soaked, I had to pee and I have heat rash all over my forehead from the sweat.  Catbox, your comment helped me regain my composure as goddess..lol
 — Isabelle5

disappointing, with all these comments I was expecting more
 — unknown

More, such as what?  Is the reunion of spirits causing the marvels of the Northern Lights not enough?  

What would you add to make this better?
 — Isabelle5

I like this

'nestled in smooth satin'  - cliche?
 — unknown

Well, it might be.  I don't read many poems about coffins but they do seem to come with satin linings.  I like the image of bones being tucked in to sleep in satin sheets.  
 — Isabelle5

Another random, coughed up in time for Halloween!
 — unknown

really, really nicely done - very gothic, very good - could I just make one suggestion? In line 12, would you think about using 'resemble' instead of 'look like'?
 — opal

Sure, suggest away, Opal.  

Now I'm thinking they reflect ....so shall I.
 — Isabelle5

well I still have a preference for 'resemble' but 'reflect' is good too, in that it deepens the meaning and the image really well.

Opal (I got logged out)
 — unknown

Just for you, Poet Friend.  
 — Isabelle5

Oh. look at that!  A returning ghost dancing for me just when I need it!
 — Isabelle5

What a nice surprise, not at all what I expected from the title. Excellent opening stanza. I particularly like the use of the capital L on line 7, this and the word joyous in 10, gives the poem a peaceful heavenly feel. The last line reminds of the song ‘The Northern Lights of Auld Aberdeen’ (where I’m from) - thanks :o)
 — hobby

so so so ON.  Incredible.  Again, NOT what I expected at all from the title, but I like that.  Very precise...intricate even.  
I love this...every detail.  10  fav
 — themolly

It's still only 5.5 - go figure.
 — unknown

definate focus on after-life not after-death! Beautiful imagery and a wonderfully positive tone.
 — Vicky-Liz

0.582s