poetry critical

online poetry workshop



snailtrail
hank

like a snail without a shell
 1
i have left a lot of myself
 2
behind
 3
in order to move
 4
 
 
and not finding a patch
 5
of moist grass before sunrise
 6
am destined to dry
 7
dead on the pavement
 8
in the mid-day air
 9

30 Aug 05

Rated 8.5 (8.3) by 2 users.
Active (2):
Inactive (1): 8, 8, 9

(define the words in this poem)
(451 more poems by this author)



Add A Comment:
Enter the following text to post as unknown: captcha

Comments:

Nice idea. I might suggest changing dead to dying for some additional oomph, the almost statement-like lines are a little flat otherwise. I'm not sure about Line 4 and 5 either, you could try merging the two, or keeping only one, as both don't seem necessary.
 — unknown

i think dead on the pavement has more oomph than dying. dead is dead. suggestion about 4 and 5 considering. thanks.
 — hank

ok.
 — hank

I liked dying more, because of the previous - destined to dry line, which implies the present continuous, I.e.: it's still drying, still dying. I also assumed you were talking about yourself in metaphor rather than a real snail. Dead seems a bit dramatic for a human, dying keeps the metaphor open. I'm a highly disagreeable critic, ask anyone. Though I don't really care whether you change or not, I leave that up to you.

The edits make all the difference, I might even clap were it not unseeming for a curmudgeon.
 — unknown

Did I mention dry and dying are phonetically close?
 — unknown

i liked this a lot, really unique idea. not much to crit here in my opinion, except that i would drop the hyphen in mid-day; midday is correct. creative; i wonder how you happened to htink of this?
 — Catbox

Its a shame , you would think snails would move quicker without their shell and keep out of the sun .
 — unknown

one might think. it's a matter of where you are at the time.
 — hank

never despair

there is always nair
 — unknown

come wittle snail

come come wid me

i have a shell for you so warm and wet and sweet

Pussy
 — unknown

thsi is a really good poem. i really like it and it makes sense
 — unknown

i really liked this poem!
 — mmoneypenny

0.275s