poetry critical

online poetry workshop



The Cost of Knowing
dmartin

Was I the bad guy
 1
for knowing she would never live
 2
past the age of thirty-eight
 3
but loved her nonetheless
 4
pretending I didn’t know
 5
what I was about to lose?
 6
 
 
Or did she deserve to know
 7
that she wouldn’t see
 8
her son grow to be a man?
 9
Should she wonder
 10
why her husband settled
 11
on a broken horse?
 12
 
 
It was the price he paid for knowing
 13
and the same for her not.
 14
No one deserves to be God,
 15
but the challenge lies within,
 16
do you give in and forewarn
 17
or live a life of agonistic selfishness?
 18

23 Sep 05

Rated 9.5 (8.5) by 2 users.
Active (2): 9, 10
Inactive (6): 5, 6, 8, 8, 10, 10

(define the words in this poem)
(142 more poems by this author)

(1 user considers this poem a favorite)



Add A Comment:
Enter the following text to post as unknown: captcha

Comments:

Very original subject! I applaud you on this concept. Minor adjustments: the tenses are confusing, and the changing of 1st person. Other than that, nice work.
 — winter

great writing
 — unknown

This makes me want to tear out my hair and throw ashes.  
 — Isabelle5

so sad.......so touching....
 — UrbanAng3l

what a terribly painful situation and a sweet poem.
 — kitkat

Why is no one reading and rating this?  It's worth many readings!

So says I.
 — Isabelle5

When I stumble upon a poet that moves me, I'm like a dog with a bone. I can't let go. This is extraordinary. The only thing that nags at me (pun or not) is that you seem to be comparing the wife to a broken horse.

You write great!
 — unknown

i like this in many ways, but there are places it doesn't quite work for me. I find the last verse akward, especially lines 16-18. 'the challenge lies within' is a cliche...and 18 feels clumsy too...so...

is there a way to say these things in a less 'conceptual' way. perhaps the questions are obliquely there within the poem and don't need to be splelt out.

how about
'either way/it was the price he paid for knowing/and the same for her not...
and ending it there?

hope some of this is useful
 — berrykid

the cost of reading this is quite expensive. do you accept refunds? it has nice ideas but could be more crisp and wittily written.
 — unknown

you deserve a very Nobel Prize
 — unknown

Hi,
Nice writing, but I agree with berrykid, the poem should end on L14.
Rgds  
 — hobby

Wow worded very well..i enjoyed reading that
 — LuberLips

0.464s