poetry critical

online poetry workshop



Ashes
Ananke

1.
 1
He was an
 2
awkward boy,
 3
mildly autistic.
 4
He smiled and
 5
burst into flames,
 6
and it seemed the
 7
ashes were heavier
 8
than the air--
 9
they did not waver
 10
like falling leaves
 11
or fall gently
 12
as the snow,
 13
but were pulled,
 14
as if magnetic,
 15
to the ground.
 16
 
 
2.
 17
We replaced the
 18
screens in our windows
 19
with mosquito netting
 20
to prevent ashes
 21
from fluttering in--
 22
greasy ashes
 23
of a burnt out dream.
 24

6 Aug 03

Rated 9 (7.8) by 2 users.
Active (2): 8, 8, 10, 10
Inactive (9): 5, 5, 5, 7, 8, 9, 10

(define the words in this poem)
(62 more poems by this author)

(4 users consider this poem a favorite)



Add A Comment:
Enter the following text to post as unknown: captcha

Comments:

A hyphen is used to connect a compound word. I know the dashes were not meant in this way but instead to connect two separate thoughts (after air in part 1 and after ashes in part 2), therefore a space should also be used. This may sound trivial but it really isn't - when reading poetry, the reader needs to know when to stop, pause, etc., as they also need to know when a connection is being made between two thoughts.
I'm not sure about the content of the poem - I will read it again and comment later.
 — unknown

sorry, I meant after 'air' in part 1 and after 'in' in part 2.
 — unknown

This is so sad! Dreams burned up, the heart-house blocked from the memory of their damaged child because the ashes stick. It's beautifully done.

Isabelle5
 — Isabelle5

There, I've made them into dashes rather than hyphens. Really, though, with either one, you're not supposed to put spaces in.
 — Ananke

...than the air -
they did not waver...

...from fluttering in -
greasy ashes...

Yes dear, you must put spaces in, otherwise you are hyphenating the two words and not the two thoughts.
 — unknown

I'm sorry, I'm afraid I disagree, as do the grammar books I just double checked (Strunk & White and Hacker) . In rare cases, it is sometimes set apart with spaces, for aesthetic reasons and on the web only. But I'm quite confident that the way I have it here is correct.
 — unknown

This is pretty good. You are probably the best poet on this site. -Moth
 — unknown

I wish it was longer...
 — inashadow

This is way underrated...
 — unknown

Nice Job. I am giving it a TEN, 1) because it deserves it and 2) Because if it gets bumped into "recent best" people will be interested in reading it again. I will say this much, though... It's a good thing this "IS A POEM". Otherwise, you might be in trouble. If not, you might get hit up by the "Poetic God" who comes on here and informs you that your poem is "NOT A POEM". Yeah... What an ASSHOLE. He gets on and says pompously that your poem is "NOT A POEM". Like someone died and made him the almighty literary judge of all things poetic. Watch out for him and don't take ANYTHING he/she says to heart. Tell him to blow it out his asshole.
 — aforbing

i like this alot but the last stanza is sort of iffy for me - I am not sure if it needs more or if it just doesn't need to be there at all . otherwise -a-ok
 — unknown

YAY. beautiful.
 — dooks

It seems unfinished.
 — unknown

I like it. I'm not sure I understand it, but I like it just the same.
 — kaze

GOOD POEM, I LIKE IT!!!
 — crazy

softly heartbreaking.  i really like the flow.
 — SteelAngel

this is beautiful
it makes me think of a friend of mine who is very dear to me
 — sparrow

This is so old and it's still on my favorites list.  I'm still impressed by the creativity and depth of the chosen words.  
 — Isabelle5

Beautiful images
 — SordidShade

beautiful.
 — trochee

gorgeous poem.
 — varun

0.501s