poetry critical

online poetry workshop



To be me is to see he
almasree

To be or not to see me-
 1
free rhetoric I am
 2
willing to embrace;
 3
thanks for the question
 4
though.
 5
 
 
I think it's me thinking
 6
out loud unless it
 7
was you pretending
 8
to be me while I sit
 9
here pretending to
 10
be free when I am
 11
not.
 12
 
 
I plead mis-degree;
 13
ironic as it may seem
 14
I believe that all young
 15
people deserve the chance
 16
if only to throw it away
 17
willingly and blame
 18
themselves...
 19
the government is guilty
 20
in other lands.
 21
 
 
I don't know
 22
which thoughts are mine
 23
and which were grown
 24
into me while I was asleep
 25
and now I wake up
 26
dissappointed-
 27
bootleg my revenge.
 28

13 Jun 08

Rated 8 (8) by 1 users.
Active (1): 8
Inactive (0):

(define the words in this poem)
(10 more poems by this author)



Add A Comment:
Enter the following text to post as unknown: captcha

Comments:

Any suggestions?
 — almasree

The main problem with this is it is almost totally abstract.  Abstract words do not appeal directly to the senses.  They do not indicate things you can touch, taste, feel, see, hear.   You do handle words well and I hope you work out some new things, one hopes you find things like calves, hats, water, cars, baseballs, physical encounters, lies, killings, heart attacks, brain tumors, bedbugs, keyboards, dumbbells, dogs, deer, paper, wood, glue, fire, ice cream.  And so on.

Also, I think this just seems to be too navel-gazy for me.     I can't seem to figure out about what it is about it I should care.  About, that is, or out.  Probably you are talking about something I can't even see.  Not the first time, if so.  These lines get at me a little, I don't know why:

the government is guilty
in other lands.

Something to do with young people  that should be having the right to fail, a dubious proposition at best.  After an unsuccessful toss-off Shakespeare reference (I've done those too) and an entirely made up second strophe, your third strophe veers into blaming the government and we reach S4.  There we find out you were asleep (presumably in this poem) and don't know which thoughts were which.  Great.  When you figure it out go tell someone else.  You're not the only one disappointed in that ending.

I'm sorry I couldn't be more positive tonight, but you wanted a reaction and this is all I've got.  
 — eric

I appreciate the comments eric and I'll try to work out the kinks in the poem. But maybe you should give the poem a second chance.

That part about the government being guilty in other lands is playing around with the idea that education should be free for everyone and whether they choose to throw that opportunity away should be their choice and their choice alone. ( not the government's unwillingness to provide free education).

One day people will wake up and realise that most of what is absolute in their lives is actually nothing more than ideas that were implanted in their heads by others.....they've never come up with an original thought in their lives.....even the prejudices are borrowed. When that day comes, things will change if only on a personal level.

Thanks again, eric.
 — almasree

edit
 — almasree

Definitely not what I was going for. I guess its too abstract and vague to mean anything, but amazingly enough it makes perfect sense to me.  The caffeine  has that affect on me.
Thanks DL.
 — almasree

0.624s