poetry critical

online poetry workshop



cocos island
hank

swam up to a rock that cousteau had signed
 1
and lots of others too, that was in the pacific
 2
 
 
where you felt like there was no world
 3
least not one you'd be interested in
 4
 
 
water fell far
 5
way down the flipping face of the thing
 6
and just...vanished into the sea
 7
 
 
and when you got there
 8
two dozen blips, bad man...bad men
 9
with bill fish  bull shit
 10
 
 
once while swimming underwater
 11
I met a shitload of sharks
 12
all just going about their business
 13
 
 
the size of station wagons
 14

6 Oct 16

Rated 8 (8.7) by 1 users.
Active (1): 8
Inactive (2): 8, 10

(define the words in this poem)
(439 more poems by this author)



Add A Comment:
Enter the following text to post as unknown: captcha

Comments:

you don't need "that was in the pacific" - it's superfluous and feels clunky to boot. it's a small poem, you can afford economy.

otherwise I really enjoyed. my favourite part is the flipping face of the thing.

cheers for the read,
 — PollyReg

yes I do
 — hank

your call. however, your grammar is awkward/wrong. why would you want to keep it like that if its been pointed out to you?

swam up to a rock in the pacific
cousteau had signed and lots of others too (better, stilll iffy)

in the pacific i swam up to a rock
cousteau signed, lots of others too...

swam up to a rock costeau signed (don't need had, either)
and lots of others too,

(because of the title we already know its in the pacific)

best of three?

the way it is now, your 'was' should be were and the comma not there. it reads wrong.

if you like it how it is, that's fine. if you could explain to me why it needs to be that way, even better.
 — PollyReg

Of course, you mustn't take me seriously, because If it were mine it would likely say this:

Wearing a swimming costume made of lycra, on a day that was affluent with weather, I breast-stroked over to a rock. I'd been swimming for a while but I am of athletic, yet stocky build. I was all tingly with endorphins. To be honest, it was quite a workout. The bliss I was feeling reminded me of this one other time, above a burger shop. I had been hastily dispatched to a cherry-haired bastion. We made origami bibles out of my spun pubes and flung cigarette butts out the window. We were aiming for the portly pedestrian and what do you know, we succeeded! Wicked!  Anyway, this rock, on this other particular day, was not an origami bible or cherry-o-baby. This rock was in THE PACIFIC. Far be it from me to get my placements mixed about. This rock was called Cocos island. If you would like to read a bit more about this please check out Wiki. Cousteau had once signed this rock. Many other's had also signed it.  I find this poetically significant. My name is John Weston and my address is 33 Mockingbird Lane, Springfield. I am gluten intolerant and yet I like to eat pancakes for breakfast. Don't give me feedback on my poems lest i am intentionally rude to you.

lol, howz about that one? :-)

(if you don't require feedback just put a footnote next time. if you like to receive it, 'thank you' would have sufficed.)
 — PollyReg

and, of course I meant 'macrame' bible, lol
 — PollyReg

polly thanks for the input...really
i love the rewriting of the poem
but it stays
 — hank

yw - shrug. white space is part of your poem. Move it to its own  line? Give it a home of its own? Without a comma?
 — PollyReg

Keep as is cos Hank knows best. It's the artist in him. Not least.
 — bettalpha

^it's an illustrative piece, that's for sure. i probably should change my score.
 — PollyReg

This is an interesting read.  Not sure whether or not i like it, but it has merit in places.  In L2, a period and not a comma should follow "too" where "That was in The Pacific" is a new sentence.  Otherwise you've got some interesting language happening here ("flipping" as opposed to "fucking," L6.)  L9's "bad man...bad men" seems out of place and for ME, tends to weigh down the following line.  I'd suggest that you let it go from "two dozen blips" right into L10's "with bill fish bull shit."  The flow would improve this way.  In L12, I'd use "came across, came upon, discovered or even happened upon" over the current, "met."  When I think of "met," I think of meeting someone and sharks are more like someTHINGS.  In L14, I'd pluralize "size" - "the sizes of station wagons.  
 — starr

seems to me none of you know how to move. you're stuck.
 — hank

polly and hank swimming in the sea...p.i.s.s.i.n.g

go'on hankster, at least move the words 'that was' on L2

for your reward i'll make you a sarnie. i'll even fetch the mayo. :-)
 — PollyReg

the name hank makes me think of henry rollins
 — PollyReg

0.223s